Let me preface by saying Firestarter (the book) is very precious to me. It is the literary equivalent of Buffy: The Vampire Slayer in my life. For a brief bit of context, right after starting high school, my family moved from a city in Connecticut to a small country town in Georgia. I was under the impression we’d only be there for a year, so I didn’t see a need to make friends with anyone and I spent my lunch time in the library reading books. Teen horror/mysteries were my favorite and that year was spent going through what the library had to offer… instead of eating and/or socializing.
My introduction to Firestarter had been a year or so earlier. I LOVED watching shows and films on the Sci-Fi channel (I guess it’s Sy-Fy now?). One night I stumbled upon Firestarter 2: Rekindled, and I was obsessed… Sidenote, maybe I should rewatch it and give my thoughts. Anyway, I was going through books in the library, came across Firestarter, thought of Firestarter 2: Rekindled, and decided to read it. If memory serves me correctly, I finished the book within four days, which I think is impressive for a kid who was in school most of the day and had homework and whatnot. I couldn’t put the book down. Even when I reread it, I get lost in it and find it hard to put down.
I say all that to say that this book is very near and dear to my heart, so adaptations will be judged harshly… and I wasn’t a fan of this film. To be fair, I don’t think I was a big fan of the first film either… from what I can remember of it. The things that made this book so special to me were missing from the film, and there were things that were added and I wasn’t sure why. (I may have to get my hands on a physical copy to see if there is commentary and/or special features that can give me better insight.)
First, let’s talk about the three main characters, Charlene “Charlie” McGee, Andrew “Andy” McGee, and Rainbird. If you’re unfamiliar with the story of the book, here’s some background. In college, Andy signs up for this experiment, if I remember correctly, he does it for the money, but also to get in good with a professor? (It’s been a while since I reread the book, though his reasonings aren’t too important.) A government outfit called The Shop is testing something called Lot Six, and it goes wrong, but they are gaslit into thinking the horrible things they saw, like someone clawing their eyes out for example, didn’t happen. Andy meets a beautiful woman there… I can’t remember her name and refuse to look it up… who eventually becomes his wife. Andy and his wife develop abilities from Lot Six. Andy calls his The Push. It’s basically him going into someone’s mind and making a suggestion. For example, when they are on the run, he has a life coaching type business where he basically pushes people not to do whatever they are doing. For example, if someone wants to stop smoking, he gives them a mental push so they no longer desire cigarettes. His wife’s powers are more subconscious. From what I remember, she seemed to have very low abilities of telepathy and telekinesis, and maybe a bit of premonition.
They go about their lives… and have a child… Charlie. That’s when things get interesting for them. See, they end up passing abilities to her, but in a different way. Charlie also has some premonition abilities, but more importantly, her Push creates fires. Eventually, the government outfit that tested Lot Six finds out that Andy and his wife got married and produced a child… and they want her. That’s basically the gist of the story, Charlie and Andy on the run from the Shop.
Now, if you’re not familiar with the story of the book, this would be the time to turn around, as we’re entering spoiler territory.
For those who already know, the reason it is just Charlie and Andy on the run is because they kill the wife. It doesn’t seem like they meant to, but they had been watching the McGees and when Charlie didn’t return home one day, they thought they fled when in actuality, she was just at a sleepover. They came to the house, the wife probably made something fly across the room in fear and they killed her.
What I love most about this film is the relationship between Charlie and Andy, but also the relationship between Charlie and Rainbird… I also just really love Charlie in general. She’s a child, but a badass. The father/daughter relationship reminds me of the same dynamic in other media I’ve loved, Claire/John in Heroes, Buffy/Giles, Sydney/her dad (whatever his name was) in Alias. The first part of the book is about them on the run.
This all comes to a head at a farm showdown, where the reader first gets to see what Charlie can do… and also makes the discovery, via Andy, that Charlie isn’t afraid of her power, she’s afraid because she likes her power. The film COMPLETELY changes this part of the story, to my disappointment. In the film, there is a confrontation at the farm, but instead of Charlie showing an exciting peak at the destruction she can cause, in the film, Rainbird ends the confrontation in a matter of moments by killing the three officers that arrive at the farm.
In the book, this is when Charlie and Andy are captured and brought to a compound in Virginia. In the film, Andy is taken and Charlie runs away. In the book, this is when we move to Charlie and Rainbird’s relationship. Charlie and Andy are obviously separated and both handle it differently. Andy feels defeated and just becomes a fat slob who can no longer push. He loses all hope. Charlie is a fighter and fights all attempts to win her over… However, their secret weapon is Rainbird. She doesn’t know he was at the farmhouse. She just thinks he’s an orderly. Nonetheless, she still ignores him like everyone… Until a fateful day when there’s a power outage.
Andy rediscovers his Push power, he ends up pushing himself because he gets a sense that Charlie is in danger. And at the same time, Rainbird pretends to be afraid of the dark so Charlie will comfort, and thus open up to him. He then becomes a substitute father for her. This results in her agreeing to let them test her powers, which is a fatal flaw for the Shop. The film has NONE of this.
The final showdown happens just when Andy and Charlie are about to escape. Andy gets word to her by pushing people, as everyone thinks he no longer has his power, so he isn’t a threat, not to trust Rainbird. Rainbird is VERY intuitive and immediately notices a shift in her behavior with him. They meet in a horse stable, but Rainbird is already waiting up above, and his plan is to kill Charlie, which has been his plan all along.
If I remember correctly, he has Charlie, or he has a gun pointed at Charlie. Minor note, I forgot to mention that Andy’s Push hurts him. Charlie uses her power without any pain, she just needs a source of water to direct it to after. Andy has been told that if he keeps using his power, it will kill him. So, in this final conflict, right as Rainbird is about the kill Charlie, and I think part of Charlie wanted him to do it, so maybe her dad could get away, Andy pushes Rainbird with all his might to jump down, and it basically kills Andy (I think Rainbird might have shot him too). As Andy is dying, he tells Charlie to burn the place down.
See, as a baby, they knew of her abilities, and they had to condition her not to use it. Being on the run forced Andy to reverse that conditioning and the Shop, in testing her, taught her to control her abilities. Rainbird fires at Charlie, but she is already using her powers, and she melts the bullet… and Rainbird, destroys the compound and the story ends with her going to a magazine to tell her story.
The film… is very different.
Charlie is never captured. She goes of her own free will, to find Andy. When she does, he pushes her to burn the place down. The burning down was very anticlimactic for me. It gave me little Carrie vibes. She reaches Rainbird and starts to use her power on him, but doesn’t. Then she leaves the facility and falls to the ground. He comes and picks her up and he walks away as the credits begin.
I was so confused.
I’m not 100% opposed to making changes to material. Even if you’re making a remake, your vision will be different from the original. That’s always going to be the case. I also think this would have done better as a mini-series, so there was more time to go into everything and build the relationships. The only reason I cared about the characters in the film was because I knew the characters from the book. It wasn’t clear to me why Charlie didn’t kill Rainbird, and it wasn’t clear to me why she would let him take her at the end.
I will say I enjoyed the acting, as well as the special effects. I can’t explain it, but I really liked that it seemed like Charlie’s screams were a part of her power. That was cool. Also, the actress who played Charlie, Ryan Kiera Armstrong, did a great job. Apparently, she was nominated for a Razzie for this film and there was such a backlash, rightfully so, that the Razzies will now only nominate adults. And for anyone who thinks she can’t act, I suggest you watch AHS: Double Feature. She was INCREDIBLE in that. (It seems people may be confusing a lack of character development with bad acting.) I also really liked seeing a female version of Captain Hollister.
Honestly, I just keep going back to miniseries. There was a lot about this world that I wanted to know more about, especially regarding the Shop. It seems Cap had some type of power, but they never go into it. They had these contact lenses that stopped Andy’s power, and I wanted to know more about that. It just seemed like the film rushed through so much at the end, but spent too much time setting up the family dynamic. I had avoided watching the film because I was afraid I wouldn’t enjoy it.
It’s definitely a popcorn film, and maybe someone who hasn’t read the book would enjoy it more because there’s nothing to compare it to. Like I said in the beginning, this story is very precious to me and this felt like a very watered-down version. So much was missing, but we also spent time on things that ultimately didn’t have significance in the overall story. I don’t know. It could have been worse, but it could have been better.