I’m going to start by saying I love the
Saw franchise. It has
sentimental value to me, which I’ll explain, so if you’re looking for a blog
bashing the series, even the. films I didn’t like as much, this won’t be it.
If my blogs haven’t made it clear, I’m a horror fan and have been since
childhood. I’m a child from the Blockbuster era and have watched all kinds of
horror. I don’t remember how or why I watched the first
Saw, nor do I
remember what I initially thought of it. The series wouldn’t pop into my mind
again until 2006.
I was 18, had just moved across the country to Phoenix, Arizona, and had
started my college/adult life. A classmate I’d chatted with online invited me
to go to the mall’s movie theater and watch the premiere of
Saw III
with him. Having only watched the first one, he invited me to his apartment to
watch the first two before we walked to the mall to see the third. We were
BLOWN away! The entire walk home we spent gushing about how much we loved the
trilogy. And we were pretty inseparable after that. Shortly after, we became
roommates, but he moved out of state before
Saw IV came out. We told
each other we’d wait until we could watch it together (I did watch it before
him, sorry I lied Adam). After that, I started watching the
Saw films
every Halloween… though I didn’t watch any of the rest in theaters.
Now onto the films. Let’s start where it all began,
Saw. I’m not
sure if it has aged well, but that could just be because I have watched it so
many times. Regardless, giving credit where credit is due, that ending was
BRILLIANT. It is up there with
The Sixth Sense and
Fight Club
for best twist endings for me. It was a great story, and I loved the intimacy
of it all.
Saw II is a film I don’t hate, but I don’t love either. I liked
that it had a group of people going through the test (we’ll come back to that
later.) It was really interesting to see Amanda get tested again. Sidenote,
Amanda is EASILY my favorite character in the franchise, and I knew Shawnee
Smith from watching
Becker. If you haven’t watched
Becker,
she plays this ditzy assistant (I believe she was an assistant or something
along those lines). So, I was VERY shocked to see her as Amanda. Having the
“contestants” for lack of better term, slowly learn they all have a
criminal background, were all put away by the same person… and that the son
of the cop who framed them and put them away is in the house with them, was
interesting and added tension. The twist at the end was nice (being that Eric
Matthews is in search of his son, but the game was already played, and his son
is literally in a safe in the room with him, but he didn’t know it.)
Saw III will probably always be my favorite of the franchise. It
means so much to me and I LOVED how it adds context to the events that came
before (the franchise will do this with future films… and sometimes I liked
it, sometimes I didn’t.) There are many things I love about this film, so here
we go. Something that is used again (not as well, in my opinion) is playing
with the viewer’s assumptions. The film starts with a woman and man in bed
together. They are arguing and she gets up to leave. Her name is Lynn and she’s
a doctor. As she is heading out the door, the man tells her he wants a divorce.
I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this because you naturally assume they are husband and wife.
You don’t learn until the VERY end of the film that Lynn is cheating on her
husband with that man. SO BRILLIANT! For this game, Jeff is playing because he
has let the death of his son consume his life… to the point that he is
neglecting his daughter. (Another nice touch is Jeff telling his daughter that
mommy wouldn’t want to see them like this. It makes the viewer believe the mom
is dead.)
In my opinion, those going through the game usually aren’t very likable. As
I write this, I think the most likable ones were Adam and Lawrence from the
first film. I say that to say I didn’t like Jeff. I sympathized with him… to
an extent, but he irked me. Maybe I can’t relate because I am not a father and
haven’t lost a child… but each part of the game was him encountering someone
involved in his son’s death. Now, these people didn’t abduct and kill his son.
His son biked into the street and got hit by a car. It was an unfortunate
accident… but Jeff treats these people like they purposefully killed his son.
One woman was a witness who ran from the scene and didn’t testify, then there
is the judge who presided over the case. Finally, there is the man driving the
car that hit Jeff’s son. Even in the flashback, you see that this man is pained
and in tears for taking this child’s life… Jeff rubbed me the wrong way, and
his eventual ending seemed like just deserts. In Jeff’s defense, he does
attempt to save them all, even if at the last minute. He saves the judge, but
the judge is killed while trying to save the driver.
Another twist I loved in
Saw III was learning the test was for
Amanda. See, Amanda thinks the test is for Lynn, and while Lynn is technically
being tested, it is really Amanda. She is meant to be Jigsaw’s legacy, but she
makes unwinnable games. I could go on and on about this film, and maybe someday
I will. But let’s move on for now.
Saw IV I enjoyed. Officer Riggs was a character I liked seeing go
through the game. As in, I thought he was a good person. It was a nice take,
seeing Jigsaw actively recruit someone. It was also interesting that this film
picks up right where
Saw III left off. The lesson he is being taught
is he can’t save everyone. As such, each segment of his game is essentially
telling him to do nothing. The person he sees in his game is in the middle of
their own test, and it is up to them to get out of it. As he goes, he seems to
be learning, and you have hope for him… until the finale. At the beginning of
the film, he bursts through a door and is told you NEVER go through an
uncleared door. He does the same in this game and that causes Eric Matthews to
get his head smashed by two big bricks of ice. We also learn that
Saw III and
Saw IV were happening at the same time.
Saw V is a favorite of mine. It is probably top 3 for me (
III is
1 and
Saw is 2). As I stated regarding
Saw II, a group going
through a game is really interesting to me. The twist I loved about this film
was the final two learn, during the final part of the game, that they were
supposed to go against their instincts and work together. Naturally, they
didn’t, resulting in only two making it to the end. The film also has Meagan
Goode and Julie Benz.
At this point, let’s talk about Mark Hoffman. He is probably the character I
hate the MOST in the series. Much like Amanda did, Mark makes tests more to get
people out of the way, making tests people can’t get out of. He was such an
antagonist, and I didn’t understand why he kept escaping punishment.
Saw VI wasn’t a favorite of mine. This film has something to say,
which isn’t a problem, but it felt a bit preachy. Mark Hoffman takes on the
head of the insurance company that denied John Kramer’s claim when he was
seeking treatment for cancer. It has a twist like
Saw III, but it
didn’t land the same way. The head of the company, I don’t remember his name,
is going through the game, and you see a mom and son, you assume that is his
wife and son. There is also a reporter who is at the end of the game with them.
When the head of the company gets to the end, you realize the reporter is his
sister, his only family, and the mom and son are related to a man who died because
his claim was denied, like John’s. Funny enough, this year while watching, I
realized the dad was Charlie on
Scandal.
I felt bad for the head of the company, because he seemed to have learned
his lesson, but still died in the end. The real twist is when Jill, John’s
ex-wife, puts Mark in the iconic bear trap… but he survives… and the movie
ends.
Saw: The Final Chapter is my least favorite. It was a 3D film, and
I’m wary of 3D horror films. The pinkish, thick blood was also a choice. This
film, and
VI, had games that involved other people who were basically
just there to die.
III and
IV had people involved in the
“protagonist’s” game… but in
III, they were there to test
Jeff’s need for vengeance and in
IV, Riggs was meant to see the others
playing their game and how they deserved to be in their test. In
VI,
for the most part, these were people who just happened to work for the company,
and it seemed unfair to punish someone for making a living by working for a
company, whose policies they may or may not agree with. Like
VI, the
people involved with the game had done nothing wrong.
The Final Chapter starts with a game involving three people caught
in a love triangle. It felt a little… trivial. The purpose of the test is so
people appreciate their lives, being in a love triangle didn’t seem a strong
enough reason to do so, but, c’est la vie. This film follows a man, Bobby, who
claims he survived a Jigsaw test and has become successful from writing a book
about it. We learn that Lawrence survived the first film and quickly learn that
Bobby is lying. I don’t remember who of his team knew this information, but his
fiancé didn’t. He has to go through the test, saving the people who work for
him. Surprise, they all die. His fiancé is at the end, and he fails to save her
as well. Of all the victims of the series, she was the one I felt the worst
for, because she had done nothing wrong, other than love the wrong man.
This films always have a B plot where the cops are working the Jigsaw case.
In this film, the police are trying to keep Mark Hoffman from killing Jill.
They fail. Terribly. And he puts Jill in the bear trap and kills her. It’s
towards the end of the film, so you think all is over… but then Mark gets
attacked. We discover Lawrence has been helping John since surviving the first
film. He locks Mark in the original
Saw arena, and the film, and
series ends…
Until 10 years later when
Jigsaw comes out. I really enjoyed the film,
and it had some nice twists. It’s 10 years after John Kramer’s death, but the
games have started again.
Jigsaw and
Spiral have more of a
police procedural feel than the previous films. This is also a group game,
which I enjoy. Each test is for one specific person, as opposed to them working
together to solve a problem. The twist in this film is the game we’re watching
actually was Jigsaw’s first game. We also learn that the Jigsaw of this game was
someone who was saved from the original game. He helped John throughout his
games… I didn’t like this. Messing with the past too much is never a good
thing in a franchise. It was the perfect amount up to around
V. Even
bringing Lawrence back for the “final” film was a nice touch. But
then having more people be a part of the past makes it harder to enjoy
rewatching the films.
Finally, as far as we know,
Spiral: Book of Saw (though now that I
think of it, I’m pretty sure I read that Tobin Bell is returning as Jigsaw). I
didn’t hate this film; I didn’t love this film. This felt the most like a
police procedural. It also felt more like a psychological thriller than a
horror film. My first time watching the film was just the other day. I’ve never
been able to guess the twist of a Saw film before. Almost immediately, I had an
idea of who the new Jigsaw was… and after a certain “death”, I knew
for certain that person was the killer… and at the end, I was right. There
was still a bit of a surprised at the end, which was nice. The change of the
Jigsaw voice was… hard to cope with. I was VERY surprised that the story was
about crooked cops and what not (which is what made figuring out the new Jigsaw
so easy, this person was the only one who wasn’t a crooked cop, so it just made
since they weren’t really dead.)
All in all, I love this franchise. It’s so inspirational how these two
filmmakers made this amazing franchise and went on to make other amazing
franchises. I’ve gone on long enough. Maybe next year I will write a blog for
each film on its own.